Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711 Comparison Review Between PPF, MK and PF

The Nautilus by Patek Philippe is undoubtedly one of the most popular models ever created and holds a significant position in the watch industry. Whether you’re in search of a sports watch or a casual timepiece, the full stainless steel Patek Philippe Nautilus is often considered one of the top choices. Similar to the Rolex Submariner, there are several watch manufacturers that produce replicas of the Nautilus, including MK, PF, and PPF. MK was the first factory to produce Nautilus replicas and continues to be a popular option among buyers. PF, on the other hand, claims to make the best Nautilus replicas, and more recently, PPF has released their V2 edition, which has gained attention. All three factories produce high-quality replica Patek Philippe Nautilus watches, leading to confusion for many buyers. To assist you in making the best choice, I will provide a detailed comparison review of these three factories.

The Nautilus from PPF, PF, and MK is constructed using 316L stainless steel. It features a case diameter of 40mm. In comparison to PF and MK, PPF’s case is thinner, measuring 8.5mm, which brings it closer to the dimensions of the genuine watch. The case finish is brushed, while the beveled edge of the bezel is polished. All three factories produce Nautilus replicas with a good case finish, as modern big factories have the capability to achieve superior case finishes

All three factories utilize sapphire crystal, known for its high hardness, in their replica watches. It’s worth noting that the sapphire crystal on the PPF Nautilus does not have an anti-reflective (AR) coating, just like the genuine watch.

In addition to its case thickness, which closely resembles that of the genuine watch, another advantage of the PPF Nautilus is its dial color. Specifically, let’s focus on the Nautilus with a blue dial. Upon comparing the dial photos of PPF and MK, it is evident that the PPF Nautilus exhibits a grayish blue hue, which closely resembles the genuine Nautilus 5711 dial color. On the other hand, the MK Nautilus has a darker blue dial color. When viewed under sunlight, the dial of the PPF Nautilus displays a vibrant and pure blue color. The authentic dial color is a significant factor contributing to the slightly higher price of the V2 PPF Nautilus compared to that of PF and MK.

The Nautilus bracelet boasts a distinctive design, featuring a wider width closer to the case and a narrower width towards the buckle. The bracelet showcases a combination of polished and brushed finishes, with the polished middle links creating a striking contrast to the brushed links on either side. In terms of bracelet finish, I believe that PPF, MK, and PF all excel. However, PPF stands out in certain aspects of the bracelet. For instance, when flexing the bracelet, the PPF Nautilus offers a more flexible feel, and the overall arced profile of the bracelet closely resembles that of the genuine watch. Additionally, the sound produced when opening and closing the buckle is indistinguishable from that of the authentic Nautilus.

The Nautilus watches from PPF, PF, and MK all utilize the Miyota 9015 movement as their base movement. The Miyota 9015 movement is known for its stability, accuracy, and low repair rate.While all three factories have modified the outlook of the movement to resemble the PP 324 Calibre, PPF has made further improvements. One notable improvement is the reduced noise level of the auto rotor in the PPF Nautilus. Some clients have reported significant noise coming from the inside movement when wearing the PF or MK Nautilus, but this issue is not present in the PPF Nautilus, representing a significant improvement.

Based on my analysis of multiple sources, including discussions on forums and comparison reviews, it is generally agreed that the highest quality replica of the Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711, particularly in the blue dial version, is produced by PPF factory. PPF is known for its authentic blue dial color and a movement rotor that does not produce noise. The latest versions of the Nautilus 5711 from PF and PPF are V2, while MK factory has updated their version to V6. These watches are sold at similar prices. Considering the overall quality and features, if you are looking to purchase your first replica in full stainless steel, I would recommend opting for the Nautilus 5711 from PPF factory.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *